First, work out what you are looking at
Aircraft are thick, often dashed by anti-collision strobes, and usually show red or green from navigation lights. Satellites are thin, even, colorless and steady. Meteors appear in exactly one frame, taper at both ends and are often brightest in the middle. If a streak appears in several consecutive frames it is not a meteor.
This matters because the fix differs. Aircraft and satellites are contamination you want gone. A meteor is usually the best thing that happened all night and you want to keep it.
| Feature | Aircraft | Satellite | Meteor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frames affected | Many, consecutive | Several, consecutive | One only |
| Brightness along it | Dashed or blinking | Even | Tapered, brightest in the middle |
| Color | Red or green present | White or neutral | White, sometimes green or orange |
| Width | Thick | Thin | Thin, widening at the flare |
| Path | Straight, often horizontal | Straight, steady | Straight, points away from a radiant |
Why deleting the frame is the wrong fix
It is the first thing everyone tries, and it produces a worse picture. Your star trails are built from every frame in sequence. Pull frame 212 out of a 400 frame stack and you have removed that slice of sky rotation from every single trail in the image. You have swapped one bright line for four hundred dark notches.
A single deleted frame in a tightly shot sequence is often acceptable, especially with gap filling to rebuild the arc. Six consecutive frames because a plane crossed slowly is not: that is a visible dashed break through the whole picture.
Three ways to remove them, worst to best
1. Manual painting in Photoshop
Stack everything, then clone or heal the streak out of the finished image. It works and it is entirely under your control. It is also slow, and it is genuinely difficult where the streak crosses dense trails near the celestial pole, because you have to reconstruct the arcs underneath by hand.
2. Editing the offending frames before stacking
Open the four or five contaminated frames, paint the streak out of each one, then stack. Better, because the trails underneath are still intact in the other frames and the blend rebuilds them for you. Still manual, and you have to find the frames first.
3. Automatic outlier rejection during stacking
The reliable one. Stars appear in every frame at a predictable position. An aircraft appears at a given pixel in one or two frames and never again. That difference is measurable, so the stacker can look at each pixel across the whole sequence, identify values that appear only briefly, and exclude them while keeping the frame.
Satrelle applies this automatically in Star Trails mode. It is aware of trail geometry, so it removes the transient streak without eating the real trails that cross it, and it does not cost you the frame. No masks, no painting, no gaps.
Automatic rejection is deliberately conservative near very dense trails and around the celestial pole, where genuine star trails can look transient. If a faint streak survives, it is usually because removing it would have damaged real data.
Reducing them at capture
- Check flight paths before you commit. A flight tracking app will show you the corridors overhead. Rotating your composition 30 degrees can move the worst of it out of frame.
- Shoot away from airports where you can. Approach and departure corridors are the worst offenders because the aircraft are low, bright and frequent.
- Accept satellites. With current constellation numbers you will not avoid them, especially in the hour after dusk and before dawn when they are still catching sunlight. Plan to remove rather than dodge.
- Shoot more frames than you need. A longer sequence gives outlier rejection more evidence to work with, and makes any single contaminated frame less significant.
Related
- Why star trails come out dashed, and how to fill the gaps
- Blurry or doubled star trails
- The complete guide to star trail photography on a Mac
macOS 12 Monterey or later · Apple Silicon
Questions
How do I tell an airplane trail from a satellite or a meteor?
Aircraft leave a thick streak, often dashed by strobe lights, and usually show red or green color from navigation lights. Satellites leave a thin, even, single-brightness line with no color and no dashes. Meteors appear in exactly one frame, taper at both ends and are usually brighter in the middle. Aircraft and satellites cross several consecutive frames, which is the most reliable way to separate them from a meteor.
Should I just delete the frame with the airplane in it?
Usually not. Deleting a frame removes that slice of sky rotation from every trail in the picture, so you trade one bright streak for a dark gap in all of them. It is only a reasonable fix if you have gap filling that can rebuild the missing arc, or if the affected frames sit at the very start or end of the sequence.
Can stacking software remove aircraft automatically?
Yes. Because a plane or satellite appears in only a few frames while the stars appear in all of them, per-pixel outlier rejection can identify the streak as transient and exclude it while keeping everything else in that frame. Satrelle does this in Star Trails mode with a rolling-window rejection that is aware of trail shape, so the aircraft goes and the trails stay intact.
Why do the streaks show up so much brighter than the stars?
Aircraft and satellites are far closer and far brighter than stars, and a lighten blend keeps the brightest value at every pixel. That means one bright pass through a single frame beats hundreds of frames of faint starlight at the same spot, so the streak wins the blend outright.